Prime Pizza Shops in Owensboro, KY
When you get that pizza craving, nothing can stop you in your search for cheese that drips from the crust and fresh, flavorful toppings. Whether you're a pepperoni pizza, a meat-lover's maniac, or voracious for veggies, you will find an incredible pick of prime pizza shops in Owensboro, KY. Forget about the national chains; our local pizzerias do it up right with thick, fluffy pizza crusts and piled-on toppings that will sate your craving or feed an entire party in style.
But which is the best pizza shop to match your tastes and make your night complete? As local pizza lovers, we're here to take you on a tour of the best pizza shops in all of Owensboro, from the funky to the feta and everything in between.
.jpg)
Mellow Mushroom - Psychedelic Pizza Bar
For a unique pizza experience and amazing stone-baked pizzas made to order, you absolutely must check out Mellow Mushroom. This psychedelic pizza bar is delightfully mushroom-themed. The Mellow Mushroom makes incredible pizzas where each thick crust is basted in garlic butter, sprinkled with parmesan, and stacked with hearty toppings. They have classcics, crazy specials, and build-your-own pizzas. They have vegan and gluten-free pizzas that are just as good.
Mix it up with calzones or amazing munchies like homemade pretzels, cheese bread, gourmet meatballs, spinach artichoke dip, and magic mushroom soup. Note: Mushrooms are shitake, button, and portobello - not actually magic. They also have great wings, salads, burgers, and hoagies.
Not to mention, the vibe is amazing. Dine under a psychedelic central tree, with the Queen of Pies painted on the glorious brick wall. The cokes are kept in red phone boxes, and the granite bar hosts some great drink options with sports on TVs only visible to bar seats.
The Oven - Local Favorite with Chicago Deep Dish
For a wonderfully traditional pizzeria experience, come to The Oven. This modest urban spot has a bright and classic downtown diner vibe with parking around the back.
What you'll love about the Oven is its thick yet airy pizza crusts and hearty distribution of toppings on every pie. If you're craving a Chicago deep dish, they can do that, too, on special request. Locals are in love with the pizza, and many have made The Oven part of their weekly routine, whether alone or with friends and family. There are tons of flavor combinations, or you can personalize them.
When it comes to sides, you'll find cheese bread and tasty breadsticks alongside alternative entrees like (very) meaty subs, flatbreads, wings, and crispy chicken fingers.
Bonus: Come for the Wednesday lunch buffet for even more pizza and a casual vibe.
.jpg)
PeezO's Pizza - Unique and Delicious
Like the name, PeezO's is not like other pizza places. It has a unique style that you won't find elsewhere. It's not New York or Chicago, but it is absolutely delicious - and at a great price. The pizzas are big and absolutely loaded, so you can't even see the crust. They also do "crustless" pizza if you need your cheese fix without the extra carbs.
PeezO's specialty is their stromboli pizza, about which the locals rave, and they do a pretty good stromboli sub alongside other meaty sandwich options. This unique little pizzeria also has unusual and delicious sides like potato skins, funnel cake fries, and cinnamon sticks, plus the usual wings and pasta.
Lastly, there's a great selection of fresh-baked cookies in numerous flavors to finish out your meal.
54 PIzza - Specialty Stuffed Breadsticks
54 Pizza has big, extremely customizable pizzas that can feed a large group with a single pie. Their big pies and welcoming, friendly vibe make them a go-to for big parties. 54 is known to treat every guest like family, and the interior is a relaxed diner-style that reminds you of your grandmother's favorite lunch cafe.
But what 54 Pizza is famous for is their handmade stuffed breadsticks. They are a not-so-secret gem of the Owensboro pizza scene, and you absolutely must try them. Stuffed with a cheese of your choice and additional pizza toppings, you will never see breadsticks the same way again.
Other items on the menu include pasta, stromboli sandwiches, and crispy calzones. We can also assure you that your chocolate chip cookie for dessert will be warm and gooey.
Fetta Specialty Pizza & Spirits - High Class NY Style Pizza
For a more fine-dinng experience, stop by the elegant Fetta Specialty Pizza & Spirits. This beautiful little pizzeria is all polished wood and charming decor with a graceful three-step brick storefront and wrought iron patio dining.
They make everything by hand, from the garlic knots to the bacon mashed potatoes. It's also one of the few places in town that serve New York-style pizza. If you like a thinner crust full of flavor, you'll enjoy pizza by the slice or the pie at Fetta.
They also offer build-your-own calzones, tasty salads, and seasonal desserts. The daily featured slices are a great way to try out new flavors at a good price, and of course, they serve beer, wine, and cocktails with your meal.
.jpg)
Explore Every Pizza Place in Owensboro from Your Apartment
Whether you're looking for your new favorite go-to pizza place or want to try every pizzeria in town, the best place to start is your Owensboro apartment. At Bluegrass Villas Apartments in Owensboro, you can begin your pizza-seeking adventures in comfort, order pizzas to your door, and enjoy slices brought home in comfort and style.
Contact us today to inquire about availability or get more awesome local tips.